Beijing’s Belt and Road plans could boost the Islamic banking sector
Huileng Tan, Evelyn Cheng
- China’s pursuit of Belt and Road Initiative projects in predominantly Islamic countries is expected to spur growth in the Islamic finance sector.
- Chinese issuers have, however, recently pulled away due to the complexities involved in rolling out such products, particularly as standards differ across various regulatory regimes, says Mohamed Damak, global head of Islamic finance at S&P Global Ratings.
Specifically, China’s Belt and Road Initiative, a regional infrastructure investment program spanning over 100 countries, has been touted as a boon for the Islamic banking sector. Such financing complies with Sharia principles, meaning it adheres to the Islamic laws that prohibit earning interest on loans and bar funding activities involving alcohol, pork, pornography or gambling.
On top of that, “some of the projects (that are) part of the (BRI) will go through some core Islamic finance countries and therefore might be financed in Sharia-compliant ways,” said Mohamed Damak, global head of Islamic finance at S&P Global Ratings.
Many of the countries along the infrastructure belt are home to predominantly Muslim populations, including Central Asian countries such as Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan.
The Islamic finance market is poised to grow to $3.8 trillion by 2022 — up from $2.2 trillion in 2016, according to Thomson Reuters calculations. It also has potential beyond Muslim countries because organizations are placing greater importance on sustainability goals and such standards often have overlapping principles with Islamic investing.
Beijing may be keen to get in on the action where the Belt and Road is concerned: State-owned news outlet CGTN published a May opinion piececheering the possibility of Islamic financial vehicles pairing with the multi-content infrastructure project.
“Given the prudent decision of the Chinese leadership to significantly expand environmentally sustainable and climate-friendly infrastructure projects, there is a distinct opportunity to unlock the combined synergies through the convergence of Islamic finance and funding of the BRI,” the author wrote.
“The Belt and Road is about supporting infrastructure development and economic growth,” said Adnan Chilwan, chief executive of Dubai Islamic Bank, the UAE’s biggest Sharia-compliant lender by assets, during an event in Dubai last October, as reported by UAE newspaper The National.
“When you talk about financing such projects, clearly there is a great opportunity for Islamic banking. It is a catalyst for bringing public and private funding together,” Chilwan reportedly said.
The BRI will be “very important” for Islamic financing and accelerate the halal trade, said Massimo Falcioni, CEO of Etihad Credit Insurance.
The potential is huge as it covers everything from food to cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, tourism, and also insurance and financials, he said.
“I think pursuing (the BRI) is a big opportunity. It will create a corridor which is not existing” and which covers 40% of GDP, said Falcioni. “It’s all an opportunity for everybody to participate.”
Meanwhile, there have been some signals about Chinese interest in the space. The China-headquartered Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank signed a memorandum of understanding with the Islamic Development Bank — a Saudi Arabia-backed institution — to collaborate on various areas including Islamic finance development.
Despite the upbeat tone from industry watchers on the potential of Islamic financing, the issuance of its most well-known and accessible product — bondsknown as sukuk — actually slowed in 2018, data show.
That was mainly due to banks affected by the sharp depreciation of the Turkish lira in 2018 and lower growth for some banks in the UAE and Qatar, said S&P’s Damak.
Sukuk issuance had grown strongly in 2017 in part from Chinese entities such as Country Garden and Beijing Enterprises Water Group issuing Islamic bondsthrough their Malaysian subsidiaries in 2015 and 2017, respectively. The companies used those proceeds to finance projects in the Southeast Asiancountry.
But Chinese issuers have actually pulled away since then. That’s been attributed to the complexities involved in rolling out such products, particularly as standards differ across regulatory regimes with varying interpretations of Sharia compliance.
“They say, ’The process is too complicated. We don’t see the economic added value to walking this route,” said Damak.
“In the past, there was some interest. There were a couple of issuers in China that have looked at the sukuk market eagerly … but they eventually decided to walk away because of the complexities related to sukuk issuance,” he said.
“They need to adjust to the regulatory environment, identify the underlying assets, structural goals, have lengthy discussions with lawyers and Sharia scholars to put together a transaction,” Damak explained.
Indeed, the United Arab Emirates’ national credit insurance agency, Etihad Credit Insurance (ECI), signed strategic memoranda of understanding with three Chinese financial giants in Beijing that will allow businesses from both countries to sell on credit to each other, and are expected to generate a value of $3 billion over the next two years, according to Etihad Credit Insurance’s Falcioni.
The three financial institutions in China are the China Export and Credit Insurance Corporation (Sinosure), Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) and Bank of China.
“UAE’s policy in the last three years, especially after the fall of the oil price, it has shifted towards India and China,” said Sankara Narayanan, team leader of country analysis for the Middle East and Africa at the Economist Intelligence Unit. He noted China’s relationships have increasingly moved from just trade partnerships to joint ventures.
— CNBC’s Yen Nee Lee contributed to this report.